Book review: Policy Guidelines for the Development and Promotion of Open Access

Policy Guidelines for the Development and Promotion of Open Access

Published by UNESCO.

Swan, Alma. (2012). Policy guidelines for the promotion of open access. (Open guidelines series). Paris: UNESCO. ISBN: 978-92-3-001052-2 Available: http://bit.ly/LXaiKK

This is a book about using mandates and sanctions to promote open-access publishing.

The author of this work, Alma Swan, currently the Director of European Advocacy for SPARC, is a zoologist and former publishing executive. The book is directed at administrators in higher education and in grant-funding agencies who are considering establishing open-access publishing policies.

Published by UNESCO, the work is prefaced by UN bureaucrat Sanjaya Mishra, who states, “Open Access is at the heart of UNESCO’s goal to provide universal access to information and knowledge, focusing particularly on two global priorities: Africa and Gender equality” (p. 6). It seems that UNESCO’s real mission is the north-south transfer of wealth, and open access to scholarly literature is one way to achieve this, thus the motivation to publish this work.

Overall the work is prolix and UK-centric. It’s mostly about open access in the STM fields (science, technology, and medicine); the arts and humanities are not considered.

The author does not hide her biases. For example, she uses the terms “double-dipping” or “double-dip” eight times in the text. Here double-dipping refers to toll-access journals that give authors the opportunity to make their work available to all; an open-access, alternative publishing model.

Moreover, Swan uses the term “mandate” in its various forms over fifty times in the work. Mandates are the chief means she recommends for getting open-access publishing up and running.

While describing open-access mandates, Swan is not shy about recommending sanctions against researchers who fail to comply with her recommended, onerous open-access mandates; she uses the term “sanctions” fifteen times in the text.

The chief failure of the book is that it fails to address the ever-growing quality problem in open-access publishing. Swan assumes that all open-access publishing is benevolent and worthy and neglects to cover the numerous publishers that have appeared in the last several years that exploit the gold open-access model for their own profit.

Also skipped is the problem of digital preservation in open-access publishing. Where will the content go when a particular open-access publisher or repository becomes defunct? The high costs associated with other aspects of the publishing process, including copyediting, managing peer-review, and information technology are also not sufficiently described.

Finally, the glossary at the end is poorly done; many terms used in the book such as “libre open access” are omitted. The book’s emphasis on enacting mandates and sanctions to enable greater access to scientific information brings to mind an important question: If the scholarly community is so supportive of open access, why do we need mandates and sanctions to make it work?

Verdict: This is not a general work on open access. Instead, the guidelines are directed mainly at policymakers who are planning on implementing mandates and sanctions to achieve their open-access goals.

3 Responses to Book review: Policy Guidelines for the Development and Promotion of Open Access

  1. Alex says:

    Having problems with the link to this book. Does not seem to work. Thanks for your fantastically useful blog!

  2. [...] though Beale’s blog can be, I do think he’s got a chip on his shoulder here. Reviewing Alma Swan’s report on open access for UNESCO, he slates her for using the term “double dipping” to [...]

Leave a Reply -- All comments are subject to moderation, including removal.

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 1,851 other followers

%d bloggers like this: